What’s the difference between a large HMO mortgage and a small HMO mortgage?

Navigating the buy-to-let (BTL) market requires understanding niche financing, especially when dealing with Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs). HMO properties—where multiple, unrelated tenants rent rooms—often generate higher yields than standard single-tenancy BTLs but introduce increased regulatory and financial complexity. For investors seeking finance, the most critical distinction revolves around the number of occupants, which determines whether the property is classed as a ‘small’ or ‘large’ HMO in the eyes of lenders and local authorities.

What’s the difference between a large HMO mortgage and a small HMO mortgage?

The distinction between a small and a large HMO is pivotal, fundamentally changing the property’s legal status, the type of mortgage required, and the regulatory burden placed upon the landlord. While both types require specialist financing different from a standard Buy-to-Let mortgage, the complexity increases significantly once the property crosses the threshold into ‘large’ HMO status.

Defining Small vs. Large HMOs

In the UK, HMO definitions are primarily driven by tenant numbers and the concept of ‘households.’ A property is generally considered an HMO if at least three tenants live there, forming more than one household, and share a kitchen, bathroom, or toilet. The key divergence is based on the statutory licensing requirements imposed by central and local government.

The Five-Tenant Threshold

For mortgage purposes, the definition often hinges on this crucial number:

• Small HMO: Typically houses 3 or 4 tenants who form two or more separate households. While still classified as an HMO and requiring compliance with specific regulations (such as fire safety), they do not automatically trigger mandatory HMO licensing across England and Wales.
• Large HMO (or Mandatory Licensed HMO): Houses 5 or more tenants who form two or more separate households. This threshold automatically triggers mandatory HMO licensing across all of England and Wales, requiring the landlord to apply to the local authority for a specific license.

If you are planning to convert or purchase an HMO, it is crucial to understand the rules set by the local council. You can find detailed mandatory licensing information on the relevant government website.

The Impact on Lending and Underwriting

Lenders view large HMOs as inherently higher risk and more commercial in nature than small HMOs. This difference affects application processes, criteria, and ultimately, the financial products offered.

Licensing Requirements

The need for mandatory licensing significantly impacts the mortgage process for large HMOs. Lenders will require definitive proof that the landlord either already holds a valid licence or that the application for the licence has been successfully submitted and is pending approval. Failure to obtain a licence for a mandatory HMO is a criminal offence and will immediately jeopardise the mortgage offer.

While small HMOs may not require mandatory licensing, many local councils operate Additional Licensing Schemes. This means that a 4-bed HMO in one area might require a licence, while the same property elsewhere might not. Lenders specialising in HMO finance will always scrutinise the specific local authority rules applicable to the property location.

Compliance with licensing conditions ensures the property meets specific standards relating to safety, amenities, and management. For more information on mandatory licensing requirements for HMOs, consult the official guidance on GOV.UK.

Valuation Methods and Stress Testing

This is arguably the most significant financial difference between the two classes.

• Small HMO Valuation: Properties housing 3 or 4 tenants are often valued using the traditional ‘bricks and mortar’ method. This means the valuation is based primarily on comparable sales of similar residential properties in the area (standard Buy-to-Let valuation).
• Large HMO Valuation: Properties with 5 or more tenants are often valued on a commercial basis, using the ‘investment valuation’ or ‘yield’ method. The valuer assesses the property’s worth based on its proven or potential rental income rather than just the comparable residential sales value. If the property generates high rental income, the mortgage value may exceed the standard residential value, but this approach is less common among non-specialist BTL lenders.

Because large HMOs are viewed as complex, commercial investments, lenders also apply stricter stress tests to ensure the rental income can comfortably cover the mortgage repayments, often requiring a higher Interest Cover Ratio (ICR) than small HMOs or standard BTLs.

Lender Pool and Criteria

The pool of lenders willing to finance large HMOs is much smaller and highly specialised. Mainstream BTL lenders often cap their exposure at 4 tenants, or they may require the property to be structured as a semi-commercial asset if it exceeds that limit.

• Small HMO Mortgages: Available from a wider selection of specialist BTL lenders. While still requiring specialist HMO products, some lenders may offer slightly more competitive rates or lower arrangement fees compared to large HMO products, especially if the local authority does not impose additional licensing.
• Large HMO Mortgages: Almost exclusively handled by specialist and challenger banks or building societies experienced in commercial property finance. These lenders often require the applicant (the landlord) to demonstrate significant previous experience managing HMOs, usually requiring a portfolio of existing properties.

Due to the increased underwriting time and commercial risk associated with mandatory licensed properties, large HMO mortgages typically involve higher interest rates and increased arrangement fees.

Application and Financial Considerations

When applying for an HMO mortgage, lenders perform extensive due diligence on the property and the applicant. This includes checks on the property’s safety standards (fire doors, means of escape, etc.), the applicant’s existing portfolio, and their credit history.

Your previous credit performance is a key factor in determining eligibility and rates. Lenders assess your financial stability to ensure you can manage potentially higher liabilities and maintain compliance with complex licensing rules. Get your free credit search here. It’s free for 30 days and costs £14.99 per month thereafter if you don’t cancel it. You can cancel at anytime. (Ad)

Compliance and Risk

Managing a large HMO brings significantly greater regulatory risk. Landlords must adhere to the stringent conditions of their licence, which include regular inspections, maintaining high fire safety standards, and ensuring adequate facilities for the number of occupants.

While HMO investments can be highly profitable, failure to meet your mortgage obligations carries significant risks. Your property may be at risk if repayments are not made. Consequences of default can include legal action, repossession, increased interest rates, and additional charges. It is essential to budget for potential void periods and regulatory compliance costs when calculating profitability.

People also asked

How many tenants constitutes an HMO?

Legally, a property becomes an HMO when at least three tenants live there, forming more than one household and sharing facilities. However, the critical distinction for mandatory licensing (and therefore “large HMO” status) occurs at five or more tenants.

Are HMO mortgages more expensive than standard BTL mortgages?

Generally, yes. HMO mortgages involve higher perceived risk, more complex underwriting, and specialist valuation methods. This typically results in slightly higher interest rates and arrangement fees compared to standard single-tenancy Buy-to-Let products.

Can I convert a standard BTL mortgage to an HMO mortgage?

No. If you intend to convert a single-tenancy property into an HMO, you must inform your existing mortgage lender. Standard BTL contracts prohibit multi-tenancy occupation. You will be required to remortgage onto a specialist HMO product, which will involve new valuation checks and different terms.

What is an Article 4 Direction and how does it affect HMO size?

An Article 4 Direction is a measure used by local councils to restrict permitted development rights. In relation to HMOs, an Article 4 Direction typically requires a landlord to apply for planning permission (a ‘change of use’ application) to convert a standard family home (C3 use class) into a small HMO (C4 use class), regardless of the number of tenants below the mandatory licensing limit. If applicable, this adds significant complexity to the small HMO process.

Do I need an experienced landlord for a large HMO mortgage?

In most cases, yes. Specialist lenders offering finance for large (mandatory licensed) HMOs prefer applicants to demonstrate verifiable, successful experience in managing multi-tenancy properties. If you are a first-time landlord, financing a large HMO acquisition can be significantly more difficult.

Summary of Key Differences

Understanding the criteria separating small and large HMOs is crucial for the success of your investment strategy. The differences dictate which lenders you approach, the costs involved, and the level of regulatory scrutiny you will face.

• Occupancy: Small (3–4 tenants); Large (5+ tenants).
• Licensing: Small (May require local Additional Licence); Large (Requires mandatory licence across England/Wales).
• Valuation: Small (Often standard residential ‘bricks and mortar’); Large (Often commercial ‘investment yield’).
• Underwriting: Large HMO mortgages require greater landlord experience and stricter compliance checks.

Whether you are pursuing a compact 4-bed shared house or a large multi-unit investment property, engaging with a specialist broker who understands the nuances of the HMO mortgage market is highly recommended. They can guide you through the differing requirements, ensuring compliance and helping you secure the most suitable financing for your specific property class.