How can I compare asset finance providers? What happens if the asset depreciates faster than expected?

Asset finance plays a crucial role in enabling UK businesses, and sometimes consumers, to acquire essential equipment, vehicles, or machinery without significant upfront capital expenditure. However, securing the right financing means carefully comparing offers and understanding the inherent risks, particularly those associated with the asset’s declining value over time.

Navigating Asset Finance: How Can I Compare Asset Finance Providers, and What Happens If the Asset Depreciates Faster Than Expected?

Asset finance, which includes options like Hire Purchase (HP), finance leasing, and contract hire, is essentially a secured loan where the borrowed funds are specifically used to purchase an asset. Because the asset itself acts as collateral, the finance terms are intrinsically linked to its value and lifespan. Making an informed choice requires thorough comparison across several dimensions, not just the quoted interest rate.

How to Compare Asset Finance Providers

When comparing different financial institutions—whether high-street banks, specialist asset finance brokers, or independent finance companies—you must look beyond the initial headline figures. The optimal provider offers a combination of competitive pricing, appropriate contract terms, and strong customer service.

1. Evaluate the Total Cost of Credit (APR)

The Annual Percentage Rate (APR) is the most comprehensive measure of the cost of borrowing, as it incorporates the interest rate and mandatory charges. However, ensure you understand how the interest is calculated—is it fixed for the term, or variable? Comparing the total repayable amount over the life of the agreement provides the clearest picture of the true cost.

• Interest Rate: Focus on whether the rate is reflective of your business risk profile and the nature of the asset being financed.
• Fees and Charges: Look out for mandatory arrangement fees, documentation fees, and exit charges. Some providers charge penalties for early settlement, which can significantly alter the overall cost if your business intends to repay the debt sooner.

2. Assess Contract Terms and Flexibility

The length of the contract and the required residual value (if applicable, in leasing) are critical. A longer term means lower monthly payments but increases the total interest paid and exposes you to depreciation risk for a longer period.

• Deposit Requirements: Providers vary widely on the required upfront deposit, which impacts your cash flow.
• Payment Structure: Determine if payments are level, or if they are balloon payments (a large final payment, common in HP) or stepped payments (varying over time). Ensure the structure aligns with your business’s projected revenue.
• Early Settlement Clauses: Understand the mechanism for paying off the finance early. Some agreements may apply significant interest penalties, negating the benefit of early repayment.

3. Provider Expertise and Regulation

Choose a finance provider that specialises in the type of asset you are acquiring. A specialist lender for construction equipment, for example, will have a better understanding of the asset’s market value and likely depreciation schedule than a generalist lender.

Ensure the provider is properly authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). This provides a degree of consumer protection and ensures the provider adheres to strict standards of transparency and conduct. You can check the FCA Register to confirm their status.

4. Review Your Credit Position

The rate you are offered is heavily influenced by your credit history and score. Before applying, understand what lenders see. Identifying and correcting any inaccuracies can significantly improve the offers you receive.

Get your free credit search here. It’s free for 30 days and costs £14.99 per month thereafter if you don’t cancel it. You can cancel at anytime. (Ad)

Understanding the Impact of Depreciation Risk

Depreciation is the inevitable loss of an asset’s value over time due to wear and tear, technological obsolescence, or market changes. When securing asset finance, the risk associated with depreciation is allocated differently depending on the type of agreement you choose.

What Happens If the Asset Depreciates Faster Than Expected?

Faster-than-expected depreciation means that the asset’s true market value falls below the outstanding debt owed to the lender. This situation is commonly referred to as negative equity and poses risks primarily in two types of agreements:

1. Hire Purchase (HP) Agreements

In an HP agreement, you are aiming to own the asset outright once the final payment is made. Since the eventual ownership and associated risks lie with you, the borrower, unexpected depreciation can have significant consequences.

• Negative Equity: If the asset depreciates rapidly, you may find yourself owing more on the finance agreement than the asset is worth. This can trap you in the agreement, making it economically unviable to sell or upgrade the asset until the debt is reduced.
• Insurance Shortfall: If the asset is stolen or written off, the insurance payout might only cover the asset’s current market value, which is now less than your outstanding finance balance. This leaves you liable for the shortfall.
• Voluntary Termination: If you choose to voluntarily terminate the agreement (where permitted, usually after paying 50% of the total price), the provider may seek to recover any outstanding costs or damages if the asset’s depreciated condition falls below acceptable standards.

2. Finance Leases and Contract Hire

In operating leases or contract hire agreements, the depreciation risk is generally borne by the finance provider, as they retain ownership of the asset. However, the risk transfers back to the lessee (you) if specific contractual parameters are breached.

• Residual Value Risk: For agreements that use a ‘balloon payment’ based on a predicted residual value (often seen in vehicle finance), if the actual market value is significantly lower than predicted, you may need to pay the difference to the lender upon the sale or return of the asset.
• Condition and Mileage Penalties: Faster depreciation often results from excessive use or poor maintenance. If the asset is returned in worse condition or with higher mileage than stipulated in the contract, the provider will impose significant penalties to cover their projected losses on resale.

Mitigating Depreciation Risk

To protect yourself against rapid asset value loss, consider the following strategies:

1. GAP Insurance (Guaranteed Asset Protection): For vehicles and certain high-value equipment, GAP insurance can cover the difference between the insurance payout (market value) and the outstanding finance balance in the event of a total loss.
2. Conservative Estimates: When entering into agreements based on residual values, adopt conservative estimates for the asset’s end-of-term worth, even if it results in slightly higher monthly payments.
3. Maintenance Schedule: Adhering strictly to manufacturer maintenance schedules and keeping detailed service records helps preserve the asset’s value, reducing penalties upon return and ensuring a better resale price.

Finally, remember that defaulting on asset finance means the lender has the right to repossess the asset to recover their funds. Failure to comply with the terms of the agreement can lead to legal action, increased interest rates, additional charges, and repossession of the financed item.

People also asked

What is the difference between Hire Purchase and a Finance Lease?

In Hire Purchase, the borrower intends to own the asset; they make regular payments and acquire title after the final instalment, bearing the depreciation risk. In a Finance Lease, the lender retains ownership, and the borrower pays for the asset’s use over the contract term, typically not acquiring ownership at the end, though residual value risk may apply.

How does technological change affect asset finance terms?

Technological change drives rapid obsolescence, increasing depreciation risk, especially for IT or specialised machinery. Lenders may shorten finance terms or demand higher interest rates on such assets to mitigate the risk that the asset becomes worthless before the loan is repaid.

Are asset finance providers regulated by the FCA?

Yes, most firms providing asset finance to individuals and certain small businesses (Consumer Credit Act agreements) must be authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). Business-to-business (B2B) asset finance often falls outside direct FCA regulation, but firms should still adhere to high professional standards.

Can I refinance an asset finance agreement if my asset is in negative equity?

Refinancing is possible, but challenging. If the asset is in significant negative equity, lenders may require additional security or collateral to cover the current shortfall before agreeing to a new arrangement, or they may only extend the term to reduce monthly payments, increasing the overall cost.

Should I use a broker or go directly to a lender?

A broker can access multiple funding sources and may find better terms or specialist options for unusual assets. Going directly to a lender may offer a faster, more streamlined process if you have an existing relationship, but you will only receive an offer based on that single provider’s product range.

Choosing the right asset finance agreement requires diligent comparison of costs, terms, and the provider’s reputation. By carefully planning for depreciation and understanding the allocated risks, businesses can successfully leverage asset finance to fuel their growth while managing potential liabilities effectively.