Economic Downturns Impact Commercial Lending

Economic downturns significantly impacts the commercial lending sector, and commercial mortgage lending is particularly sensitive to these shifts. When economic uncertainty increases, lenders typically adopt a more cautious approach, tightening their lending criteria, while borrowers face challenges related to declining asset valuations and decreased business performance.

Economic downturns cause lenders to increase caution, leading to tighter underwriting standards, lower Loan-to-Value (LTV) ratios, and higher interest rates due to increased perceived risk. Borrowers often face difficulties securing finance as collateral values drop and business cash flows become stressed, potentially increasing the demand for specialist or short-term lending options.

Economic Downturns Impact Commercial Mortgages?

The UK commercial property market is cyclical, meaning periods of growth are often followed by contractions or downturns. When the broader economy slows—characterised by inflation, reduced consumer spending, and increased unemployment—the ripple effects quickly reach commercial finance. Understanding these impacts is crucial for any business owner seeking to acquire, refinance, or develop commercial property.

1. Lender Risk Perception and Liquidity

The fundamental change during an economic downturn is the massive shift in how lenders assess risk. During stable periods, lenders compete for business, often offering favourable terms. In a recessionary environment, the primary goal shifts from expansion to protecting capital and ensuring adequate returns against heightened default risk.

Increased Perceived Risk of Default

In tough economic times, the risk of a commercial borrower failing increases significantly. Businesses may experience reduced sales, supply chain issues, or insolvency. Lenders react by viewing all commercial loans—especially those secured against property in vulnerable sectors (like retail or speculative development)—as inherently riskier.

Liquidity Constraints

Downturns often put pressure on bank balance sheets. If the supply of capital decreases (liquidity tightens), lenders may need to ration the funds they allocate to long-term, high-value assets like commercial mortgages. This reduced supply can make securing finance harder, regardless of the quality of the application.

2. Tightening Underwriting Standards and Criteria

The most immediate and tangible impact on borrowers is the tightening of eligibility criteria. Lenders adjust key financial metrics to create a larger buffer against potential losses.

Lower Loan-to-Value (LTV) Ratios

The LTV ratio is perhaps the most critical metric affected. LTV represents the percentage of the property value the lender is willing to finance. During stable periods, LTVs for standard commercial mortgages might reach 65–70%, or even higher for specific low-risk sectors.

During a downturn, lenders require borrowers to contribute significantly more equity. LTVs may drop to 50–60% or sometimes lower, especially for properties considered difficult to sell quickly.

• Impact on Borrowers: Businesses need to source substantially more deposit capital, which can strain working capital reserves or make the purchase impossible.
• Impact on Refinancing: If property values decline, a borrower seeking to refinance an existing loan may find their LTV has automatically worsened, potentially requiring them to inject cash to maintain the new, stricter ratio.

Higher Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) Requirements

DSCR measures a property’s net operating income (NOI) against the required debt payments. A DSCR of 1.25 means the property generates 125% of the income needed to cover the mortgage payments. Lenders use this to ensure the borrower can comfortably service the debt, even if income dips slightly.

In a recession, lenders raise the minimum required DSCR, often moving from 1.25 to 1.40 or higher. They assume future income streams are unstable and demand a greater margin of safety.

Increased Due Diligence and Scrutiny

Lenders intensify their scrutiny of the borrower’s business plan, cash flow forecasts, and personal financial stability. Applications that might have been straightforward previously now require exhaustive evidence of resilience.

Lenders will focus heavily on:

• The strength of tenant covenants (for investment properties).
• The duration of leases remaining.
• The business sector’s vulnerability to recession (e.g., hospitality and leisure often face tougher scrutiny than essential services).

Furthermore, lenders will assess the borrower’s personal credit history and track record more rigorously, as this provides insight into financial discipline under pressure.

A strong personal credit report is essential for commercial finance application success, especially when personal guarantees are involved. Get your free credit search here. It’s free for 30 days and costs £14.99 per month thereafter if you don’t cancel it. You can cancel at anytime. (Ad)

3. Property Valuation and Market Instability

Economic downturns directly attack the value of the collateral securing the loan—the commercial property itself.

Devaluation of Assets

As business confidence falls and demand for commercial space decreases (due to contraction or remote working trends), property values decline. Professional property valuers become more conservative in their assessments, reflecting lower expected rental income and higher vacancy rates.

For a lender, this means the security backing their loan is worth less, increasing their potential loss if they had to repossess and sell the property following a default. This drop in valuation reinforces the need for lower LTV ratios.

Sectoral Vulnerability

The impact of devaluation is not uniform. Some commercial sectors suffer disproportionately:

• Retail: Hit by reduced consumer spending and shifts to online commerce.
• Office Space: Affected by remote working trends and businesses scaling down operations.
• Industrial/Logistics: Often more resilient, especially those supporting essential e-commerce supply chains, though still subject to overall economic headwinds.

Lenders may pause or entirely withdraw funding for the most vulnerable sectors until market stability returns.

4. The Rising Cost of Commercial Borrowing

Tighter lending standards are almost always accompanied by higher costs. This increase stems from central bank actions and the lender’s internal requirement for a higher premium to offset greater risk.

Higher Interest Rates

Interest rates rise for two primary reasons:

1. Monetary Policy: Central banks (like the Bank of England) often raise the base rate to combat inflation, which is common during certain types of downturns. This automatically increases the cost of borrowing for all variable-rate products.
2. Risk Margin: Even if the base rate remains steady, commercial lenders increase the margin (the profit percentage added above the base rate). This margin increase reflects the higher probability of default. Borrowers with complex proposals, poor credit scores, or properties in vulnerable locations will see the largest margin increases.

Increased Fees and Legal Costs

Lenders may also introduce or increase various fees, such as arrangement fees, valuation fees, and legal costs, to cover the extra due diligence required and to generate revenue from fewer completed transactions.

The rising cost of finance can make previously profitable projects unviable, leading businesses to delay investment plans or pull out of agreements.

5. Managing Existing Commercial Mortgages During a Downturn

The impact of an economic downturn is not limited to new lending; existing borrowers also face challenges.

Covenant Breaches

Many commercial mortgage agreements contain covenants (conditions) related to the property’s performance, such as maintaining a minimum DSCR or keeping the property adequately insured. If business performance falls or rental income declines, the borrower risks breaching these covenants. A breach typically triggers a review by the lender, potentially leading to:

• Requirement for immediate cash injection (curing the breach).
• Reassessment of the loan terms.
• In severe cases, moving the loan into default management.

The Challenge of Refinancing

If an existing loan reaches maturity during a downturn, refinancing becomes a difficult hurdle. The borrower must secure a new loan under the current, stricter underwriting standards, often involving lower LTVs and higher rates. If the borrower cannot meet these new standards, they may be forced into short-term, expensive alternatives, or face pressure to sell the asset in a weak market.

6. The Role of Specialist and Alternative Finance

As high-street banks retreat from risk during a downturn, the demand for specialist, non-bank commercial finance providers increases. These lenders, often funded by private capital, tend to be more flexible, though generally more expensive.

Bridging Finance

Bridging loans become critical during periods of high economic uncertainty. They offer quick, short-term funding solutions necessary for time-sensitive deals, funding acquisitions when traditional lenders are moving too slowly, or refinancing existing debt while a borrower stabilises their business ready for long-term mortgage application.

Bridging loans are typically arranged quickly, interest often rolls up (meaning monthly payments are not usually required, but the debt accrues), and the exit strategy (how the loan will be repaid) is heavily scrutinised.

However, it is vital to understand the risks involved in specialist finance. Your property may be at risk if repayments are not made. Consequences of default can include legal action, repossession, increased interest rates, and the imposition of additional charges and fees, potentially eroding capital quickly.

The Need for Expert Advice

Navigating the complex and often rapidly changing landscape of commercial finance during a downturn requires expert guidance. A skilled commercial finance broker can help borrowers:

• Identify lenders that remain active in specific market niches.
• Structure the application to mitigate perceived risks.
• Source alternative finance options when mainstream routes close off.

For more general guidance on dealing with financial pressure during difficult economic times, resources such as MoneyHelper (previously the Money Advice Service) provide impartial advice on managing finances and debt: MoneyHelper Guidance on Money Troubles.

People also asked

What happens to commercial property values during an economic recession?

Commercial property values generally decrease during a recession because market demand for space falls, rental income is expected to drop, and high-interest rates reduce the overall affordability and profitability of property investments. Valuers apply higher discount rates to future income streams, leading to lower current valuations.

How does inflation affect commercial mortgage rates?

High inflation typically prompts the Bank of England to raise the base rate to slow the economy. Since commercial mortgage rates are often benchmarked against the base rate or influenced by wider money market movements (like Sterling Overnight Index Average(SONIA)), higher inflation usually translates directly into higher commercial mortgage interest rates for borrowers.

Can a lender call in a commercial mortgage early if the economy worsens?

A lender generally cannot call in a standard term loan early unless the borrower breaches a specific covenant in the mortgage agreement (e.g., failure to make payments, breach of DSCR covenants, or material misrepresentation). Downturns increase the likelihood of covenant breaches, which empowers the lender to intervene and potentially demand immediate repayment or restructure the facility.

Is it harder to secure development finance during a recession?

Yes, development finance becomes significantly harder to secure. Lenders view development projects as high risk, especially during uncertainty. They tighten pre-sales requirements, reduce the maximum percentage of Gross Development Value (GDV) they will lend, and require developers to contribute more equity upfront, reflecting the increased risk that sales prices may fall or construction costs may overrun.

Should I fix my commercial mortgage rate during a downturn?

The decision depends heavily on the forecast for future interest rates. If you believe interest rates have peaked or will remain high for an extended period, fixing the rate provides certainty over your operational costs. However, fixed rates typically involve break clauses and potential penalties if you need to refinance or sell early, and the initial fixed rate offered during a downturn may be higher than average.

Conclusion: Adapting to Economic Headwinds

The relationship between economic downturns and commercial mortgage lending is defined by heightened caution and increased complexity. Lenders protect their capital by imposing stricter criteria—lower LTVs, higher DSCRs, and increased rates—while borrowers must present exceptionally robust financial profiles and business plans to secure funding.

Success in securing or maintaining commercial finance during challenging economic periods relies on meticulous planning, realistic valuation expectations, and, crucially, access to expert advice that can navigate the rapidly shifting risk appetite of the commercial lending landscape.